Court Strikes Humiliating Blow By Defining What a Trans Man Isn't


Advocates and supporters of the transgender community often ignore biology and science in deference to emotions and feelings when it comes to what specific or non-specific genders a trans-individual may choose to identify as.

Unfortunately for them, a high court in Germany just trumped their feelings with the science they refuse to acknowledge, and ruled that a man who has transitioned to be a woman can’t be listed as the “mother” on his/her/xir’s child’s birth certificate, according to TheBlaze.

The ruling stemmed from a 2012 case in which a transgender woman who used to be a man, but had donated sperm prior to the transition, wanted to be listed as a “mother” on the birth certificate after that sperm was eventually used to impregnate the person’s partner, and a child was born as a result.

Germany’s Federal Court of Justice, however, just upheld a lower court’s ruling against the plaintiff, due to the fact that German law held that only the woman who gave birth to the child could be listed as the “mother” on the birth certificate.

According to The Associated Press, the court ruled, “The transsexual person’s fundamental rights aren’t breached by the fact that existing ancestry law assigns her the legal status of parent according to her former sex and the specific contribution to procreation that resulted from this.”

Taylor Swift Halts Concert to Deliver Message to Young Fans, Christian Parents Won't Like This

In other words, the parent who donated the sperm that was used to create the baby must be listed as the “father” on the birth certificate. Pretty self-explanatory, at least for those of us who understand basic science and the fundamentals of biology.

German media outlet DW reported that the high court’s ruling aligned with a similar case in September in which the roles were reversed and a woman who had given birth to a child but then transitioned to be a male wanted to be declared the father, but was told she was still officially viewed as the mother.

That case has been appealed to Germany’s Constitutional Court for review.

As in that case, the court in this case ruled that even if a parent had legally changed their gender, such a change had no bearing on the legal relationship between the parent and their child.

Again, basic science is more important than feelings, at least in the eyes of the German court.

Unsurprisingly, advocates for the gay, lesbian and transgender community are outraged and are demanding the laws be changed to suit their whims.

The Lesbian and Gay Federation in Germany stated that this decision from the court made it clear that there needed to be reforms to the descent laws in the country.

They argued that the “legal recognition of the broad constellation of diversity of rainbow families must be guaranteed.”

The transgender community and those who support it think they can shift the culture to force everyone else to accept and abide by their particular lifestyle choices.

Another Disney Dumpster Fire? Here's Why Alarm Bells Should Be Ringing at House of Mouse

However, so long as the courts remain beholden to the law and fundamentals of nature which under-gird it, they are going to have a difficult time doing so.

Please share this on Facebook and Twitter so everyone can see how a German court ruling just dealt a huge blow to the transgender community’s efforts at shifting the culture.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →

We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

, , , , , , ,
Ben Marquis is a writer who identifies as a constitutional conservative/libertarian. He has written about current events and politics for The Western Journal since 2014. His focus is on protecting the First and Second Amendments.
Ben Marquis has written on current events and politics for The Western Journal since 2014. He reads voraciously and writes about the news of the day from a conservative-libertarian perspective. He is an advocate for a more constitutional government and a staunch defender of the Second Amendment, which protects the rest of our natural rights. He lives in Little Rock, Arkansas, with the love of his life as well as four dogs and four cats.
The School of Life
Little Rock, Arkansas
Languages Spoken
Topics of Expertise