AP Top 25 Heat Check: Too Much SEC Bias with 8 Ranked Teams?
The college football fans who are convinced there is bias for the Southeastern Conference in The Associated Press college football poll have a lot to complain about this week.
The SEC placed a season-high eight teams in the Top 25 released Sunday, including the only three ranked teams that have lost twice.
Maybe the haters have a point?
No. 21 Auburn has been slogging along offensively all season and dropped to 4-2 after losing at Mississippi State on Saturday night. The Bulldogs snapped a two-game losing streak against the Tigers and landed at No. 24 in the new rankings.
Texas A&M (4-2) re-entered the rankings after a 20-14 victory at home against previously unbeaten Kentucky in another grinder of a game. The Wildcats slipped five spots to No. 18.
No. 14 Florida jumped eights spots for beating LSU, which slipped from No. 5 to No. 13.
Meanwhile, other teams such has Stanford, Oklahoma State and Virginia Tech slipped all the way out of the rankings released Sunday after a second loss. TCU, which has lost only to Ohio State and Texas, is buried in the others receiving votes.
Iowa (4-1) was first out of the Top 25. Washington State (5-1) is not even close.
What gives? In October 2014, when the SEC had four of the top five teams in the rankings, research done by STATS showed that in the previous five seasons, SEC teams did not seem to be getting treated differently from other teams by poll voters when it came to movement (up or down the rankings) after conference games. There was no obvious preferential treatment for SEC teams found.
As for this season, Auburn is still riding its victory against No. 7 Washington. Texas A&M’s two losses are to No. 1 Alabama and No. 4 Clemson. Mississippi State gets a bounce based on beating Auburn, which beat Washington, and losing to Florida and Kentucky, which have only lost to other SEC teams.
Instead of cannibalizing each other, SEC teams are propping each other up, buttressed by the league’s quality nonconference performance.
Heat check understands the complaints and is also a little suspicious of continuing to reward slipping Auburn, and then in rewarding Mississippi State for beating Auburn.
Though It also should be noted that S&P+, an analytic ranking based on play-by-play data, and the Sagarin Rating also have those eight SEC teams in the top 25.
No. 1 Alabama (6-0)
Next: vs. Missouri.
The Crimson Tide is allowing 4.9 yards per play, which is 28th in the nation and would be the worst mark for the Tide’s defense since 2007.
Heat check: Just right.
No. 2 Georgia (6-0)
Next: at No. 13 LSU.
QB Jake Fromm has not gotten the type of attention Tua Tagovailoa and Dwayne Haskins have, but he is the fourth-most efficient passer in the country and could start drawing some Heisman buzz as the Bulldogs enter a challenging stretch of schedule.
Heat check: A touch too hot. Flip with Ohio State.
No. 3 Ohio State (6-0)
Next: vs. Minnesota.
The defensive issues persist. The Buckeyes are a thoroughly mediocre 60th in the nation at 5.42 yards per play.
Heat check: Too cold.
No. 4 Clemson (6-0)
Next: No. 20 North Carolina State, Oct. 20.
Behind RB Travis Etienne, the Tigers are fifth in the country in rushing yards per game (280.93) and have the second-best average per carry (6.96).
Heat check: Just right.
No. 5 Notre Dame (6-0)
Next: vs. Pittsburgh.
Mercurial TB Dexter Williams has given the Irish running game a home-run hitter the last two games with 339 yards and an 8.92 average per carry.
Heat check: Just right.
No. 6 West Virginia (5-0)
Next: at Iowa State.
With three top-eight teams losing Saturday, the Mountaineers got a raise by virtue of others dropping.
Heat check: Too hot.
No. 7 Washington (5-1)
Next: at No. 17 Oregon.
The worst-case scenario for the Huskies is Auburn tanks and the opener is not even a quality loss.
Heat check: Too hot
No. 8 Penn State (4-1)
Next: vs. Michigan State.
Must have been hard for Penn State fans to watch Indiana pass all over Ohio State and not start thinking about that fourth-and-5 run.
Heat check: Too hot.
No. 9 Texas (5-1)
Next: vs. Baylor.
Always lots of talk about body of work when ranking teams, but at some point you have to acknowledge a team is getting better. This isn’t the team that lost to Maryland.
Heat check: Too cold.
No. 10 UCF (5-0)
Next: at Memphis.
Interesting to see what the ceiling will be on the Knights. At some point the lack of signature victories will stall their climb.
Heat check: Just right.
The Western Journal has reviewed this Associated Press story and may have altered it prior to publication to ensure that it meets our editorial standards.
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.
