Share
Sports

HS Basketball Star's Parents Now Suing over Daughter's Ineligibility

Share

Last week, we brought you the story of Maori Davenport, the Alabama high school girls’ basketball player ruled ineligible by state officials over a payment from USA Basketball to cover expenses related to a trip to an international tournament in Mexico City.

Davenport’s family returned the money in full as soon as they found out the payment broke a rule, hoping that the “no harm, no foul” principle could apply, the state could drop the matter, and Davenport could get back to playing basketball at the high school level before her college days begin at Rutgers in the fall.

Alabama commissioner Steve Savarese disagreed, however, imposed the season-long suspension and for good measure vacated four of Charles Henderson High School’s wins, in the process harming the state tournament prospects for the Troy-based squad.

When the story hit the national media, it had all the ingredients for an Outrage Soufflé, which rose in the oven so well that even Billie Jean King and Kobe Bryant issued public statements condemning the decision and calling on the Alabama High School Athletic Association to reverse its decision.

Sadly, the publicity had no effect, so Davenport’s parents heeded the advice that Doug Llewellyn used to give on “The People’s Court”: “Don’t take the law into your own hands. You take ’em to court.”

Trending:
KJP Panics, Hangs Up in Middle of Interview When Reporter Shows He Isn't a Democratic Party Propagandist

They filed a lawsuit against the AHSAA and Savarese.

Mario and Tara Davenport enlisted the services of the Cole Law Firm, which won a quick victory in getting an injunction from an Alabama judge against the AHSAA.

Which, in turn, means Davenport is eligible to play Friday night, and woe betide the poor souls on the Carroll High School team who have to defend her.

Because Davenport wants to drop a performance that, in basketball terms, is dunking on Steve Savarese like she’s Vince Carter and he’s Frederic Weis.

This started out as a feel-bad story about a kid getting shafted by insensitive state bureaucrats.

Social media has elevated it to the level of a comic book superhero taking on the evil empire.

Related:
Heated Moment Between UFC's Sean Strickland and 'Vampire Man' Machine Gun Kelly Goes Viral; Stars Have to Be Separated

Jay Bilas, who signal-boosted the original message last Saturday, was instrumental in bringing the story to the nation’s attention.

Davenport herself pointed out that she would do the whole thing all over again for the honor of playing for her country.

A thing worth remembering here is that this is just a temporary injunction from the judge; a final hearing won’t be until some point later in the season.

Do you think the courts will overturn Davenport's suspension?

There’s also been some controversy involving the choice of judge, as Pike County Circuit Judge Sonny Reagan resigned as assistant attorney general in Alabama following his role in alleged obstruction of justice involving the corruption investigation against then-Alabama state House Speaker Mike Hubbard.

But ultimately, this comes down, as it did last week, to two competing doctrines, and if I may be allowed the luxury of quoting myself:

“Rules are rules” and “actions have consequences” are two of the most fundamental underpinnings of a lawful and ordered society.

But “no harm, no foul” and “it was an honest mistake, you made it right, and it won’t happen again” are the principles that mark the difference between justice and power-trip authoritarianism.

And in the court of public opinion, petty bureaucracy has been convicted on all counts of power-trip authoritarianism.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →



We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

Tags:
, , , ,
Share
Boston born and raised, Fox has been writing about sports since 2011. He covered ESPN Friday Night Fights shows for The Boxing Tribune before shifting focus and launching Pace and Space, the home of "Smart NBA Talk for Smart NBA Fans", in 2015. He can often be found advocating for various NBA teams to pack up and move to his adopted hometown of Seattle.
Boston born and raised, Fox has been writing about sports since 2011. He covered ESPN Friday Night Fights shows for The Boxing Tribune before shifting focus and launching Pace and Space, the home of "Smart NBA Talk for Smart NBA Fans", in 2015. He can often be found advocating for various NBA teams to pack up and move to his adopted hometown of Seattle.
Birthplace
Boston, Massachusetts
Education
Bachelor of Science in Accounting from University of Nevada-Reno
Location
Seattle, Washington
Languages Spoken
English
Topics of Expertise
Sports




Conversation