Johnny Depp’s new movie “Ebenezer” debuted in theaters on Friday, but critics and audiences have drastically different takes on the film.
The movie sees Depp playing Ebenezer Scrooge, the coldhearted miser from Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol.” While critics rated the film a lackluster 54 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, audiences placed it at 89 percent.
Many critics appear unable to set aside the previous allegations made against Depp by his actress ex-wife Amber Heard, even though Depp won a defamation lawsuit against her regarding the claims.
Reviews from Vulture, Vanity Fair, CNN, and others can’t help but include commentary on those past events in their reviews.
The Vanity Fair coverage is particularly telling as its author suggests he’s guilty of Heard’s dubious past claims: “Now, though, it feels as if the once chiseled-cheeked heartthrob has found a character that suits him: a monstrous figure seeking redemption.”
Audience reviews from every day Americans, however, were much more positive and much less hung up on past he-said, she-said allegations.
“Great take on a classic as usual Johnny Depp fantastic!” one audience member raved.
“The movie was a lot darker than any other version I’d seen. All the actors did a fabulous job,” another added.
“Great new gothic classic of a old tale, stellar performances all around with stand out direction and world building,” a third offered.
Rotten Tomatoes was not an outlier.
Other movie rating sites tracked a vastly different reaction between critics and audiences.
On Metacritic, critics scored “Ebenezer” at 46 out of 100, while audiences scored it at 7.5 out of 10.
“Ebenezer is good enough to stave off the boredom that often accompanies watching a translation of a timeless classic, but not good enough to make me want to watch it again,” one critic opined.
“Ultimately, the actor’s need to be loved — to claw himself out of what he fears is an early career grave, an image we see him physically do — hijacks the movie. The traditional beats don’t land,” another said.
“Ebenezer” opened with a respectable $19 million, surging to the No. 1 position at the box office, according to a report from Variety.
It’s earned $42 million from 63 markets around the world, meaning it will make back its $38 million production budget.
Signing you in…
Please keep this page open. The results will appear here.
Check your email to count your vote
We sent a confirmation link to .
Click Confirm Your Vote in that email to count your vote and unlock the results.
Your vote has not been counted yet. If the email hasn't arrived, check your spam or junk folder.
While critics and audiences often agree, sometimes their takes on movies drastically diverge.
According to an analysis on BirchTree, they are usually within 5 points of each other.
But some movies can prove especially polarizing.
For example, 91 percent of critics enjoyed “Star Wars: The Last Jedi,” while only 42 percent of audience members agreed.
The critics had similarly disparate approval for “Captain Marvel.”
On the other hand, audiences liked “Venom,” giving the film a 76 percent approval against 14 percent from critics.
The audiences liked movies such as “The Lion King” and “Grown Ups” far more than critics as well.











