A New York City department run by an Egyptian-American Muslim appointed by the city’s Muslim mayor is forcing a historic church to pay for its own unwanted and protested demolition.
This story concerns the South Bushwick Reformed Church, a church built in 1853 that recently suffered a devastating arson attack back in June.
The attack, allegedly committed by a man named John Jones, wrecked the church and left it a shell of its former self.
In response to the attack, the church’s pastor, Rev. James Steward, and his congregation began petitioning for the church’s parish hall to be preserved.
FDNY members responded to a 3-alarm fire at a church on Bushwick Avenue in Brooklyn on Friday afternoon. Units arrived within three minutes of receiving the call and quickly encountered a heavy fire condition. Within 20 minutes, the incident escalated to a third alarm, bringing a response of 63 units and 192 EMS and fire personnel.
Members remained on scene extinguishing pockets of fire and protecting surrounding exposures. The church is believed to have been unoccupied at the time of the fire, and no unusual operational challenges were encountered during firefighting operations. There was no indication of suspicious activity at the scene.
The cause remains under investigation by FDNY Fire Marshals.
— FDNY (@FDNY) June 20, 2026
“He and his small group of roughly 50 churchgoers are hoping to salvage the parish hall, which they believe is structurally sound and safe to worship in,” Spectrum News reported in July.
In a statement to the outlet, Steward fiercely defended the church.
“It is more than a building,” he said. “That’s generations of lives and ministry of work. That’s what’s behind these walls.”
“Our engineers have already, from the very beginning, did an assessment to show that the parish hall was largely unaffected,” he added.
Steward also launched a fundraiser in the hopes of rebuilding the church.
But none of it was enough, thanks in large part to the New York City Department of Buildings, which is headed by Egyptian-American Muslim Ahmed Tigani.
The Muslim man was hand-picked by Muslim Mayor Zohran Mamdani to run the department, according to City & State.
On July 14, Brownstoner published a statement from Steward indicating that the department had decided to demolish the church.
“It is with extremely heavy hearts that the South Bushwick Church reports that, despite its best efforts, we have been informed that demolition of the remaining structures at 855 Bushwick will commence tomorrow,” the statement read.
Signing you in…
Please keep this page open. The results will appear here.
Check your email to count your vote
We sent a confirmation link to .
Click Confirm Your Vote in that email to count your vote and unlock the results.
Your vote has not been counted yet. If the email hasn't arrived, check your spam or junk folder.
Steward attributed the upcoming demolition to an “order” that “was issued by the Department of Buildings.”
“Unfortunately, despite our and our team’s tireless efforts, today we learned that demolition will commence tomorrow on the parish hall,” the statement continued.
“We will take this time to mourn, but rest assured we remain committed to being a positive and continued presence in the community. We thank the community for its continued support.”
Critics immediately pinned blame for the demolition on Tigani.
!!! NYC Department of Buildings rejects plan to save a 174-year-old church in Bushwick that burned via arson
Demolition is set to begin in August
Ahmed Tigani leads the agency https://t.co/KbIwgu1vux
— End Wokeness (@EndWokeness) July 14, 2026
They also slammed Tigani for charging the church for its own demolition.
“The city will bill the church for the cost of demolition, a sum that is likely to exceed the $15,000 the church has raised so far with its GoFundMe,” Brownstoner confirmed.
Locals like Dina Alfano, co-founder of the Bushwick Historic Preservation Association, were devastated by the church’s demolition.
“[We were] trying to preserve things like the cornerstone or the steel supports with the Corinthian tops that were inside the church on either side, but any of those architectural elements unfortunately were swept away with the demolition,” she told the New York Post.
“Unfortunately, none of them were kept,” she added.











