As the Lindsay Clancy trial showed, up in Massachusetts, killing your children can evoke sympathy and support and condemnation of harsh punishment.
Things are a little different in South Carolina, where on Thursday Susan Smith, who killed her sons in 1994, was denied parole, according to an Associated Press report posted by NBC News.
Smith, 55, was convicted of killing 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex by rolling her car into a lake. She was sentenced to life without parole.
A law on the books when she was convicted said that after 30 years, she could ask for parole, and could keep on asking every two years. Smith tried to be freed in 2024, but the door was slammed shut.
“She took away one of the greatest gifts God gives us — life,” her former husband said.
“She did that deliberately. It wasn’t an accident. It wasn’t a bad mistake,” David Smith, the father of the children and Smith’s former husband, told the parole board, according to WCSC-TV.
“Thirty-two years seems like a long time to some people, but man, that 32 years for me is like yesterday,” he said.
“Experts tell us that one of the hardest things in life to get through is the death of a child. When you have to bury two at the same time by the hands of their mother, that just multiplies it a thousand times,” David Smith said.
“It wasn’t an accident. It wasn’t a bad state. She did it deliberately,” David Smith said, according to People.
“So even though it’s been 32 years that doesn’t take away from what she did to Michael and Alex,” he said. “I’m here asking you all to look in your heart and see a father’s pain, his still-broken heart.”
Susan Smith testified virtually and begged for release.
“I dropped to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake,” Smith said, according to WCSC.
“I know that David didn’t get to see Michael and Alex grow up. You didn’t get to see him ride a bike or go to school. And I’m really, really sorry for that, and I would go back and change all of that if I could, I would, OK? I’m not the same person I was 32 years ago,” Smith said, according to NBC.
Others said she did not deserve the chance, according to WCSC.
“Susan made the choice out of selfishness; she really thought she could start her life over with someone else by getting rid of these children,” Tommy Pope, who prosecuted the case, said.
“She says she’s sorry. If she’s sorry, then serve your life sentence; that’s how you show you’re sorry,” Rebecca Smith, who was an aunt of the children who were murdered, said.
Smith first claimed a black man carjacked her and the children.
“All the men, the black men, who were pulled because of the story she made up about who took these boys, every single one of those men were victims,” 16th Circuit Solicitor Kevin Brackett said.










