A heartbreaking story of a young woman who took her own life after her father sexually abused her gets worse.
The man responsible for the crime was released after just six months.
Makayla Settles had graduated from high school in North Carolina as of July 2025 when she decided to move in with her father, 41-year-old Stephen Chavez, in Moorpark, California.
The 18-year-old had her life ahead of her and was planning to begin classes at Moorpark College.
That changed on July 21, 2025, when Chavez bought alcohol for himself and Settles before he had sex with her.
She told her mother about it, and a sexual assault forensic exam took place at a local hospital resulted in Chavez’s arrest and charges against him.
The VC Star reported that Settles tried to get past what happened but could not. She took her life in December 2025, dying in a hospital a week after a suicide attempt.
Chavez entered a guilty plea after being charged with incest and providing alcohol to a minor. He was sentenced in June 2026 to one year in jail and three years of probation. He will also register as a sex offender for 20 years.
He changed his plea after an offer from Judge Dusty Kawai of the Ventura County Superior Court.
Deputy District Attorney Tessa McCarty and Settles’ family wanted three years, but Kawai imposed a one-year sentence in Ventura County Jail noting Chavez’s lack of a criminal history, saying the defendant’s consent was required for a longer period of incarceration.
District Attorney’s Office spokesman Joey Buttitta explained why Chavez is already a free man.
“Although the court imposed a one-year sentence, California law allows eligible defendants to receive credits that reduce their actual time in custody by 50%,” he said.
As of his release on Nov. 9, Chavez spent 5 months and three weeks in jail.
Settles’ mother, Carolina Sandoval, commented on his release.
“It hurts all over again. It’s yet again another date that we have to remember, and it’s painful,” she said.
“My daughter’s life meant way more than six months.”
How can you walk away from this story believing that California does not protect sexual predators?
Chavez should be in prison for the rest of his life at minimum. A young woman is dead after suffering his horrible abuse.
He can now go about his life freely.
We must also worry about other young women Chavez could victimize. Sandoval said as much: “If he starts drinking, I absolutely think it would happen to somebody else.”
She has since filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Chavez with a trial beginning this Friday.
Blue states are lenient with sexual predators. The evidence speaks to it, in spite of what leftist influencers like Jennifer Welch would have you believe. During a recent episode of her “I’ve Had It” podcast, Welch concluded, “When I see somebody that says they are MAGA, and especially if they tack on the MAGA Christian… I immediately think pedophiles.”
💥Jennifer Welch smears *ALL* of MAGA as “P*DOPHILES”💥
“When I see somebody that says they are MAGA … I IMMEDIATELY think: ‘p*dophiles!’ That’s just where we are. MAGA are p*dophiles or p*dophile protectors.”
This type of rhetoric creates a permission structure for violence.
It seems like a textbook example of stochastic terrorism.
— Jason Cohen 🇺🇸 (@JasonJournoDC) November 15, 2026
Reality says otherwise. Democrats protect this vile behavior and give the perpetrators light sentences.
A young woman is gone because of her father’s evil abuse.
He is free because of Democrats’ justice system.










