3 Prominent Republicans Who Ran Pro-Choice Ads Suffer Big Losses, While 1 Who Stood Strongest for Life Wins
On a night when Republicans absorbed heavy losses across the map, three candidates who chose to blur or abandon the party’s traditional stance on abortion suffered clear defeats.
In Michigan, former U.S. Rep. Mike Rogers posted a video responding to attacks on his record, describing abortion as “one of the hardest decisions a woman will make in her entire life.”
Instead of defending the right to life, Rogers said it “should be handled with her family and her doctor.”
I have been clear about this issue time and time again and I will not allow Abdul to lie about my position.
This decision is one of the hardest decisions a woman will make in her entire life and it should be handled with her family and her doctor. Period.
The Michigan voters went to the ballot box and made a woman’s right to choose part our State Constitution and as Michigan’s next Senator I will never go to Washington and overturn the will of the Michigan people.
— Mike Rogers (@MikeRogersForMI) October 31, 2026
Rogers added that Michigan voters had placed a so-called right to abortion in the state constitution and that he would not go to the Senate to overturn it.
The phrasing matches language long used by candidates who support legal abortion. For a lawmaker who had previously maintained a pro-life record, the shift was abrupt, and Rogers lost.
@MikeRogersForMI Was it worth it??
— Christina Pushaw 🐊 🇺🇸 (@ChristinaPushaw) November 4, 2026
In New York, Nassau County executive and gubernatorial candidate Bruce Blakeman ran as an openly “pro-choice Republican.” His materials told voters he trusted women to make their own reproductive decisions.
Blakeman was already known for that position and still received the nomination, but he lost the race for governor.
I know some of you have never voted for a Republican before. I’m not asking you to start.
I’m asking you to vote Affordable, for a Governor who is pro-choice, will cut taxes, and will finally make New York affordable.
— Bruce Blakeman (@NassauExec) September 20, 2026
In Minnesota, former NFL sideline reporter Michele Tafoya similarly aired ads identifying herself as a “pro-choice Republican” while supporting limits after the first trimester. She lost her Senate bid.
These were not isolated incidents.
Candidates who treat the protection of unborn life as an optional or negotiable position have repeatedly failed to expand the Republican coalition while simultaneously demoralizing a core part of it.
Evangelical and Roman Catholic voters who prioritize the issue do not treat it as secondary.
Family Research Council President Tony Perkins noted after the results that the party cannot take those voters for granted and must respect their voices.
“The Republican Party, coming out of this… cannot take any of their voters for granted.
Those pro-life evangelicals and pro-life Catholics that make up the core of the Party, Republicans are going to have to respect their voices and work with them.”
–@johnrogersal, @cygnal https://t.co/hADLHsBouY
— Tony Perkins (@tperkins) November 4, 2026
When Republican nominees adopt the framing of the other side, many of those voters stay home or withhold support.
Even if the tactic produced short-term gains in some races, it would remain the wrong course. A party that claims to value human dignity cannot treat the intentional murder of an unborn baby as a private medical preference free of public consequence.
Signing you in…
Please keep this page open. The results will appear here.
Check your email to count your vote
We sent a confirmation link to .
Click Confirm Your Vote in that email to count your vote and unlock the results.
Your vote has not been counted yet. If the email hasn't arrived, check your spam or junk folder.
The act of abortion ends the life of a precious child. It also carries documented risks and lasting effects for many women who undergo it.
Treating the question as settled by state ballot measures or by the language of “choice” does not erase either reality.
South Carolina offered a different example on the same night.
Attorney General-elect David Stumbo publicly pledged that if equal protection legislation for the preborn becomes law, he will enforce it. He won a statewide race in an otherwise difficult environment for Republicans.
This could be huge for the pro-life community, if state legislators follow through.
— Palmetto State Watch (@WatchPalmetto) November 4, 2026
Republican voters want to know whether their nominee will fiercely defend the party’s core principles or dilute them for a softer message.
In an election where loss of trust in the Republican establishment was a major theme, Republican candidates would do well to remember this in future cycles.
Advertise with The Western Journal and reach millions of highly engaged readers, while supporting our work. Advertise Today.
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.
