San Francisco Takes Drastic Measure to Force Schools to Reopen Amid Record Mental Health Crisis
The number of suicidal children in San Francisco has hit a record high and health experts say that keeping public schools closed “is catalyzing a mental health crisis among school-aged children,” according to a lawsuit the city filed Thursday to push its school district to reopen classrooms.
San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera announced last week he was taking the dramatic step of suing the city’s own school district, which has kept its classrooms closed for nearly a year.
In the motion filed in San Francisco Superior Court, Herrera cited alarming testimony from hospitals in the San Francisco Bay Area, doctors and parents on the emotional and mental harms of extended remote learning.
One mother, Allison Arieff, said she had recently found her 15-year-old daughter “curled up in a fetal position, crying, next to her laptop at 11 a.m.” Arieff said her daughter often cries in the middle of the day out of frustration and “is losing faith not just in [the San Francisco Unified School District] but in the world.”
Another mother, Lindsay Sink, has seen a “major regression” in her 7-year-old son who has “uncontrollable meltdowns that turn [the] whole house upside down.”
Sink’s 10-year-old daughter is experiencing “depression and anger” and she fears her daughter’s “mental health will continue to suffer” until in-person learning resumes.
UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital has seen a 66 percent increase in the number of suicidal children in the emergency room and a 75 percent increase in youth who required hospitalization for mental health services, the lawsuit said, quoting pediatricians, child psychiatrists and emergency room doctors.
Last month, UCSF Children’s Emergency Department at Mission Bay reported record high numbers of suicidal children seen and treated, according to the legal filing.
It also quoted doctors citing an increase in anxiety, depression and eating disorders among children, consistent with national data.
“The medical evidence is clear that keeping public schools closed is catalyzing a mental health crisis among school-aged children in San Francisco,” Dr. Jeanne Noble of the UCSF Emergency Department said.
San Francisco’s 52,000 public school students have been kept out of classrooms since March.
Public health officials have allowed city schools to reopen since September, but the district and teachers unions have not been able to finalize a deal on reopening classrooms.
“We wholeheartedly agree that students are better served with in-person learning,” the school district’s spokeswoman, Laura Dudnick, said Thursday. “Bringing students back to school in a large public school district is very complex and requires partnership.”
“We are eager for the city to make vaccines available to our staff,” Dudnick said.
The lawsuit is the first of its kind in California and possibly the country, as school systems come under increasing pressure from parents and politicians to end virtual learning. It has prompted discussion in other cities including Los Angeles, where a city councilman is urging similar legal action to force schools open.
The lawsuit highlights the growing tension nationwide between politicians who insist it is safe to return to classrooms and teachers who refuse to do so without receiving vaccines.
Those in favor of reopening classrooms cite data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showing that the risk of COVID-19 transmission in schools is low.
Rochelle Walensky, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said this month that teachers do not have to be vaccinated in order for schools to reopen safely.
The lawsuit notes that 114 of San Francisco’s private, parochial and charter schools have reopened to 15,831 students and some 2,400 staff. Those schools have had fewer than five cases of suspected in-person transmission, it says.
“Distance learning is a form of instruction; it is not school,” the lawsuit says. Keeping kids out of schools “constitutes a substantial violation of their constitutional rights.”
The Western Journal has reviewed this Associated Press story and may have altered it prior to publication to ensure that it meets our editorial standards.
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.