Family Collecting Seashells Confronted by California Authority, Fined $88,000
Editor’s Note: Our readers responded strongly to this story when it originally ran; we’re reposting it here in case you missed it.
Charlotte Russ was not expecting the dramatic end to her vacation in Pismo Beach, California, that she ended up receiving.
Toward the end of the trip late last year, the Fresno, California, resident oversaw her children gathering what they thought were seashells off the beach, according to KFSN-TV in Fresno.
However, Russ and her children soon learned the dire consequences of their activity.
“They thought they were collecting seashells, but they actually collected clams — 72, to be exact,” she told the outlet.
California has regulations to protect the Pismo clam, and there are penalties for violating those regulations.
Russ was ticketed immediately by state Department of Fish and Wildlife officials and later received a notice in the mail that said she was expected to pay a fine of more than $88,000.
She said she was both shocked and saddened by the grotesque amount of money she now owed.
“It was just really sad, it made me really sad and depressed, and you know, it kind of ruined our trip,” Russ said.
It was a sentiment that for most people would be a massive understatement.
“The reason … we have these regulations is because we have to let them get to four-and-a-half inches so they can spawn, so they can have offspring every year, and they have juvenile clams,” Lt. Matthew Gil from the Department of Fish and Wildlife told KFSN.
Fortunately, though, Russ’ story had a happy ending.
After explaining the misunderstanding to a San Luis Obispo County judge, her fine was reduced from more than $88,000 to a mere $500.
Not a small sum, to be sure, but definitely more manageable for the average American mother than the original fine.
Clearly, though, the five-figure fine for the innocent actions of Russ’ children was grossly out of proportion to the offense.
Though humans are called to be stewards of God’s creation, the pursuit of good stewardship and wildlife conservation should be balanced by an understanding of human foibles and mistakes.
The local judge thankfully exhibited the human side of the justice system, understanding that Russ and her children, not being locals, could easily mistake the clams for seashells and gather them up by mistake.
Responsible stewardship involves creating laws and regulations that conserve the environment without forgetting the human quotient.
Otherwise, more people will end up getting fined more than $88,000 for an honest mistake.
It certainly made for a trip that Russ and her children are not likely to forget anytime soon.
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.
