A California judge has dealt a blow to Democratic California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s authoritarian aspirations.
Sutter County Superior Court Judge Sarah Heckman ruled on Monday that Newsom’s executive order that mail-in-ballots be sent to every registered voter in California was unconstitutional, the Washington Examiner reported.
Heckman’s ruling won’t affect the current election — following Newsom’s executive order, mail-in voting was passed by the state legislature — but it does send an important message to Newsom regarding separation of powers and the limits of his emergency powers.
In June, Newsom issued Executive Order N-67-20, mandating the issuance of mail-in ballots, citing the California Emergency Services Act.
California State Assemblymen Kevin Kiley and James Gallagher responded by filing a lawsuit claiming Newsom had exceeded the bounds of his authority under the CESA.
Heckman ultimately agreed with Kiley and Gallagher in her decision.
“The CESA allows the Governor, during a state of emergency, to issue orders and regulations and to suspend certain statutes, but the plain and unambiguous language of CESA does not permit the Governor to amend statutes or make new statutes,” she wrote.
“The Governor does not have the power or authority to assume the Legislature’s role of creating legislative policy and enactments. Because Executive Order N-67-20 amended sections of the Elections Code it exceeds the Governor’s authority under CESA and renders Executive Order N-67-20 invalid.”
In other words, the CESA allows the governor additional powers in times of emergency, but those powers are not unlimited. The governor cannot use the guise of an emergency to push through his preferred policies without opposition.
This is a win for those who believe in checks and balances and the separation of powers.
Heckman’s decision won’t affect today’s election because, in between Newsom’s order and Heckman’s ruling, the California state legislature passed legislation providing for mail-in voting in the state.
Gallagher said he and Kiley actually voted in favor of that legislation. Their lawsuit was not about mail-in voting per se; rather, it was about the process.
They chose to challenge Order N-67-20 because they thought it represented Newsom’s “most egregious overreach.”
However, that doesn’t mean Heckman’s order is ineffective or simply symbolic: Heckman included a permanent injunction enjoining Newsom from similar overreach.
“Gavin Newsom, in his official capacity as Governor of the State of California is enjoined and prohibited from exercising any power under the California Emergency Services Act (Government Code $ 8550 et seq.) which amends, alters, or changes existing statutory law or makes new statutory law or legislative policy,” the order states.
“Executive Order N-67-20 issued by the Governor on June 3, 2020 is void as an unconstitutional exercise of legislative power and shall be of no further force or effect.”
Hopefully, other leftist governors take note that they do not have total authority, even in times of “emergency.”
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.