Op-Ed

History, Basic Economics Are Clear: Price Controls Would Destroy Heath Care

Today’s Western Journal stories in the AI you already use.

Get WJ in AI

Which AI do you use?

Get a short reading list with links to the stories.

Use another app or get help

Copy this request into any AI chat that can read the web. You can also paste it if signing in opens a blank chat.

Create today's Western Journal brief. Pick up to five stories published in the past 24 hours, including Commentary when available. Use my known interests and any topics I picked. If neither is available, choose a broad mix. Read https://www.westernjournal.com/ai-briefing/ first. If unavailable or the snapshot is over 15 minutes old, try https://www.westernjournal.com/ai-briefing.txt, then open https://www.westernjournal.com/llms.txt with ?edition=YYYY-MM-DD-HHMMZ using the current UTC date and minute on each run. Read its inline list through the end marker. If needed, try https://www.westernjournal.com/latest-news/, then the directory’s public story JSON, then https://www.westernjournal.com/feed/, then search site:westernjournal.com. Link each original headline directly to its verified WJ article and say in one sentence why it matters today. Add utm_medium=AI_brief and add utm_source=<the short lowercase name of this AI> if missing. Start your first reply with this exact line: Welcome to The Western Journal AI news and commentary brief! Below is a sample of what your brief might look like based on what your AI already knows about your interests. After the brief, add “Daily delivery options”. If scheduling is available, say “I can set this up to arrive automatically every day.” Offer 6 AM, noon, or 5 PM in my likely time zone, and let me pick another time or zone. Confirm both before saving or updating one daily briefing. Say whether it was saved or scheduling is unavailable. Each run should use these same sources and preferences and deliver just the brief. Use this app’s daily scheduling feature if available.

The Western Journal

Price controls sound like a great way to control costs. The government will just set a ceiling on price, and nobody will be allowed to charge more than that. What could go wrong?

Everything. Always.

Many Americans are too young to remember the gasoline shortages of the 1970s. They’ve seen great swings in the price of gasoline — it jumped during the early 2000s, then plunged again after the market collapse of 2008. But there’s never been a shortage of fuel, the way there was in the 70s. In those days, the price of gas was low. But there wasn’t any to buy.

When the federal government tried to set a ceiling on the price of gasoline, it set it too low. Producers would have lost money on every sale, so they didn’t produce. That’s what always happens with price controls. The below-market price always means that the quantity supplied will be less than the quantity demanded, eventually resulting in a shortage.

The problem, as Austrian-British economist F.A. Hayek pointed out, is that no government has access to all the information that is available in a market.

That brings us to health care, one of the most regulated businesses in the United States today. Some want to make it even more regulated by essentially imposing price controls. The reason this time is to stop “surprise medical billing” (SMB).

SMB happens when an insured patient accidentally uses an out-of-network provider. This can happen because the patient is taken to an ER and doesn’t know whether the hospital is in-network. It can even happen within a hospital, where some practices aren’t covered by every insurance plan.

This practice allows insurance companies to skip paying some bills and can even send patients into bankruptcy. Admittedly, SMB should not happen. But the proposed solution is actually worse than the problem.

Lawmakers are looking at ways to impose price controls on health care. They may go with a plan that imposes arbitration on disputed medical bills. Or, they may rally behind a different proposal, one that uses the in-network charge as a benchmark and bans rates higher than that.

What these proposals have in common is that they are both forms of price controls. They would use the power of the government to set rates. This would end up helping insurance companies but could harm patients and doctors.

Insurance companies are the biggest beneficiaries of today’s broken system. They are earning record profits, even as they try to pass bills along to innocent consumers. They are spending tens of millions on lobbyists in Washington, aiming to get policies enacted that are even better for them. They love the idea of price controls, because then they can start squeezing compensation downward.

Of course, if insurance companies are able to pay doctors less, there will likely be fewer doctors. Some will retire early; others will go into teaching or research. Why see patients if you’re going to lose money?

Related:
Housing Market Struggles May Signal Incoming Economic Crisis

Fewer doctors means less availability, which hurts patients. As always with price controls, the idea sounds good, but if the product (health care) isn’t available, the price doesn’t matter.

There is a better solution to all of this, and that is to empower the market. Instead of giving insurance giants more control, lawmakers could give patients (consumers) more choices. Allow them to choose their own insurance plans. Give them the same tax benefits we give to employers. Allow them to negotiate on price and service. Eventually, costs will come down and service will improve.

If some insurance companies end up going out of business in this new environment, they’ll be replaced by companies that are more consumer-friendly. That, too, would be a win for patients.

Modern health care is seldom simple. The solution to surprise medical billing won’t be simple either. But one thing is certain: Price controls are the wrong approach.

The views expressed in this opinion article are those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by the owners of this website. If you are interested in contributing an Op-Ed to The Western Journal, you can learn about our submission guidelines and process here.

Choose The Western Journal as your preferred source on Google and never miss reporting that defends truth, protects freedom, and advances Western civilization

Advertise with The Western Journal and reach millions of highly engaged readers, while supporting our work. Advertise Today.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →



We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

Michael Busler, Ph.D., is a public policy analyst and professor of finance at Stockton University, where he teaches undergraduate and graduate courses in finance and economics.




Tags:
, ,

Conversation