Share
Commentary

Ex-ICE Chief Goes Scorched Earth: Illegals Walk to America but Can't Make It to Court

Share

A federal judge ruled on Tuesday against President Donald Trump’s policy that made it more difficult for certain illegal immigrants to get a bond hearing.

The administration policy set in place two months ago said that those illegals could be detained until their asylum case is completed.

However, U.S. District Judge Marsha Pechman disagreed and ruled that illegals should be released from custody if they are otherwise eligible for bond.

The controversy over whether Pechman’s ruling was correct hit its peak during a hot segment on Fox News’ “The Ingraham Angle.”

The two guests were immigration lawyer Gunther Sanabria and Thomas Homan, former U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement acting director.

Trending:
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, Feels 'Rejected' as 'Homesick' Prince Harry Looks for New Residence

Sanabria opened blaming Trump for the “bottleneck” conditions at the border. “Donald Trump has stopped the bond hearings, has stopped the power that the judges have to decide a case and this is what is happening,” Sanabria said. “We have overcrowded jails, an overcrowded system. The judge said enough. We can fix this problem. The law allows us to give them a bond hearing, and that is what we’re going to do. There is no reason why we are holding a mother, father and child in a detention center waiting days and sometimes months for a bond hearing. This is our system. Our legal system allows the judges to grant a bond based on certain requirements.”

But Homan wasn’t going to sit by and let such an assertion go unchallenged.

The reason why bond was previously denied is because most asylum seeking immigrants fail to show up for their bond hearings, according to Homan.

Do you agree with Thomas Holman about illegal immigrants?

“Because they’re likely to abscond. Look at the data. The data’s clear: 90 percent of [illegal aliens] are in absentia, which means they didn’t go to court. That’s just the facts,” Homan argued.

Acting Homeland Security Secretary Kevin McAleenan previously confirmed that 90 percent figure.

Sanabria disputed that statement with no evidence other than asserting that all of his clients show up in court.

Related:
Jim Jordan Threatens Letitia James with Subpoena Over Trump Prosecutor

“They’re absolutely accurate,” Homan said, defending his statistics. “If you look at those claiming asylum at the border, almost half of them don’t even file a case in immigration court.”

And then Homan dropped the hammer.

“It’s incredible they can find a way from Central America to the United States, but they can’t find a way to an immigration court in the city they live,” Homan said. “But I guarantee they’ll find a way to a welfare office. I guarantee they’ll find a way [a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services office] to get employer documents.”

And Homan may not be wrong.

Chris Conover, in a study from the Center for Health Policy and Inequalities Research at Duke University, confirmed Homan’s sentiment by showing that “illegals throughout the country cost taxpayers billions a year.”

“All told, Americans cross-subsidize health care for unauthorized immigrants to the tune of $18.5 billion a year,” Conover said.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →



We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

Share
G.S. Hair is the former executive editor of The Western Journal.
G.S. Hair is the former executive editor of The Western Journal and vice president of digital content of Liftable Media.

After graduating law school from the Cecil C. Humphries School of Law, Mr. Hair spent a decade as an attorney practicing at the trial and appellate level in Arkansas and Tennessee. He represented clients in civil litigation, contractual disputes, criminal defense and domestic matters. He spent a significant amount of time representing indigent clients who could not afford private counsel in civil or criminal matters. A desire for justice and fairness was a driving force in Mr. Hair's philosophy of representation. Inspired by Christ’s role as an advocate on our behalf before God, he often represented clients who had no one else to fight on their behalf.

Mr. Hair has been a consultant for Republican political candidates and has crafted grassroots campaign strategies to help mobilize voters in staunchly Democrat regions of the Eastern United States.

In early 2015, he began writing for Conservative Tribune. After the site was acquired by Liftable Media, he shut down his law practice, moved to Arizona and transitioned into the position of site director. He then transitioned to vice president of content. In 2018, after Liftable Media folded all its brands into The Western Journal, he was named executive editor. His mission is to advance conservative principles and be a positive and truthful voice in the media.

He is married and has four children. He resides in Phoenix, Arizona.
Birthplace
South Carolina
Education
Homeschooled (and proud of it); B.A. Mississippi College; J.D. University Of Memphis
Location
Phoenix, Arizona
Languages Spoken
English
Topics of Expertise
Culture, Faith, Politics




Conversation