Commentary

Girl Suing to Join 500-Year-Old Boys' Choir Loses Court Case

A boys’ choir without a single female member in its over-500-year history was handed a huge win from a judge this week, dodging an accusation of discrimination.

The accusation originally hit State and Cathedral Choir, a German all-boys group affiliated with Berlin’s University of the Arts, after a 9-year-old girl’s application was rejected.

After auditioning, the girl was told she simply lacked the talent and motivation to be a part of the choir.

According to Germany’s Deutsche Welle, the discrimination complaint stemmed from the girl’s mother.

The resulting court case divided the country as supporters of the choir squared off against gender equality advocates.

Trending:
Megan Rapinoe Comes Under Fire After Racist Comment from Her Past Surfaces

Despite the existence of other choirs, the parents insisted on suing.

According to a German travel information website, the country has about 60,000 choirs.

The choir maintained that its decision to not accept the young girl into its ranks was “not predominantly about her gender.”

The presiding judge appeared to agree with this.

Did this judge make the right call?

The artistic freedom of the historic choir apparently had great weight in the judge’s final decision, which said the acoustic pattern of the group and their “boys choir sound” meant that the rejection was not discrimination.

Supporters of the choir were ecstatic, and many saw the decision as a major victory for the cultural icon.

The State and Cathedral Choir was founded in 1465, predating the German state itself, and has never had a female member.

For now, it looks like that tradition will stand.

The choir can be seen performing briefly below in a German-language news broadcast.

Related:
Conservatives Fighting Back in the Culture War: The Daily Wire Announces New Film 'Run Hide Fight'

With masculinity under continued assault from modern culture, classic activities like boys’ choirs are increasingly finding themselves in the crosshairs.

While gender and equality are both fluid concepts in many places, this choir stuck to its guns and walked away with a victory.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →



loading

We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

Tags:
, , , ,
Jared has written more than 200 articles and assigned hundreds more since he joined The Western Journal in February 2017. He was an infantryman in the Arkansas and Georgia National Guard and is a husband, dad and aspiring farmer.
Jared has written more than 200 articles and assigned hundreds more since he joined The Western Journal in February 2017. He is a husband, dad, and aspiring farmer. He was an infantryman in the Arkansas and Georgia National Guard. If he's not with his wife and son, then he's either shooting guns or working on his motorcycle.
Location
Arkansas
Languages Spoken
English
Topics of Expertise
Military, firearms, history




loading

Conversation