Amid continued concerns about the security of user data among the nation’s top tech firms, some critics continue to focus on another perceived shortcoming of companies like Twitter, Facebook and YouTube.
As Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, brought up during Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s Capitol Hill testimony last week, many conservatives believe the social media platform, among others, has deliberately diminished their voice.
“There are a great many Americans who I would say are deeply concerned that Facebook and other tech companies are engaged in a pervasive pattern of bias and political censorship,” the senator said.
His line of questioning led Zuckerberg to acknowledge that the Silicon Valley, where his and many other tech companies are headquartered, is an “extremely left-leaning place” and that he understands why conservatives might be worried.
Those concerns were explored in great detail by analysts with the Media Research Center in a new report titled “Censored! How Online Media Companies are Suppressing Conservative Speech.”
After studying banning practices, algorithms and other data available for leading social networking platforms, the report concluded that Twitter “leads” the field in terms of silencing the expression of conservative viewpoints.
Citing a controversial undercover report by the Project Veritas earlier this year, researchers concluded that Twitter has “been censoring conservatives through a technique known as shadow banning, where users think their content is getting seen widely, but it’s not.”
The alleged selective publication of content along partisan lines also included targeting specific words — like “America” and “God” — for further suppression.
As for Facebook, researchers found that the site’s News Feed has been shown to reflect the left-leaning bias of the curators tasked with selecting featured stories.
A 2016 Gizmodo report used as evidence of this argument cited former employees who confirmed the practice, prompting Facebook to promise an overhaul of the feature.
A pair of pro-Trump social media commentators known as Diamond and Silk recently accused Facebook of such bias after receiving a notification that their content had been deemed “unsafe” for the site’s community. Facebook has since apologized and indicated that the ruling had been made in error.
According to the MRC report, YouTube has experienced unique issues regarding anti-conservative bias due to the mission it shares with parent company Google.
“YouTube moderators must take their cues from the rest of Google — from shutting down entire conservative channels ‘by mistake’ to removing videos that promote right-wing political views,” the researchers wrote.
The report also used the promotional material as evidence of YouTube’s perceived partisan slant.
“The site’s very own YouTube page and Twitter account celebrate progressive attitudes, including uploading videos about ‘inspiring’ gay and trans people and sharing the platform’s support for DACA,” researchers wrote.
While the 54-page report offers detailed analysis for these and other tech giants, its authors said they could have provided much more.
“This is an extensive report, yet it could be 10 times or 100 times longer and still be incomplete,” the report read.
Truth and Accuracy
We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.