Op-Ed: Many Pro-Lifers Are Arguing Against Abortion the Wrong Way and It Could Cost Lives


New to PreBorn Americans United? Please read this introduction explaining the first-person nature of this Op-Ed.

Prior to the Civil War, slavery supporters argued in favor of letting the states decide whether to allow or prohibit slavery. They believed that was the reasonable and democratic middle ground between those for and against slavery. Their argument wrapped that evil institution in a democratic veneer known as popular sovereignty.

Popular sovereignty is a legitimate constitutional principle. However, slavery and the butchering of human beings by mass abortion-homicide aren’t issues for a referendum.

And yes, it is a scientific fact that a human being exists from the moment of fertilization, as an amicus brief filed by 70 biologists in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, now pending at the Supreme Court, affirms, stating, “The fertilization view is widely recognized — in the literature and by biologists — as the leading biological view on when a human’s life begins.”

We at PreBorn Americans United believe that the Supreme Court’s decision in the Dobbs case will overturn Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey, either by:

Hollywood Star's Wife Played Key Role in International Criminal Court's Arrest Warrant for Israeli Leaders

1. Setting aside Roe’s “viability” rule allowing states to regulate abortion prior to 24 weeks gestation when, according to that biological nonsense rule, a preborn baby is “viable outside the womb,” or

2. Ruling that we, the preborn, are constitutional “persons” according to the meaning and intent of the 14th Amendment: “nor shall any state deprive any person of life … without due process of law.”

Sadly for us, many pro-life people and organizations — led by the state of Mississippi in the Dobbs case — actually make the argument for No. 1 when they could advocate for the position in No. 2 that would completely end elective abortions. (See our criticism of Mississippi’s argument before the Supreme Court.)

Should states be allowed to protect abortion?

Some pro-life fundraising seems to assume a Dobbs ruling as per No. 1. We sincerely hope future fundraising includes a call to pray for the ruling described in No. 2.

If the Dobbs ruling allows states to regulate abortion, 20 or more will continue the Great American Abortion Holocaust, while proponents will continue to shamelessly proclaim that killing the innocent is a positive good. “Slavery as a positive good” was the Democratic Party’s rationale justifying that evil institution prior to the Civil War.

Letting the states decide the abortion question means that about 600,000 preborn babies will be butchered each year instead of 862,000. While an improvement, our national shame won’t end. We, as a nation, will be tolerating an ongoing genocide of innocent lives, more than 63 million since Roe — 10 times the Nazi Holocaust of the Jews! And we dare look down on them?

Parallel to the moral and constitutional question of letting the states decide on abortion is the same question regarding slavery that dominated the seven famous debates between Stephen Douglas and Abraham Lincoln.

In their fifth debate, Douglas remarked that “in a Territory, the people can do as they please on the slavery question under the Dred Scott decision.”

“I say to you that there is but one path of peace in this Republic, and that is to administer this Government as our fathers made it, divided into free and slave states, allowing each state to decide for itself whether it wants slavery or not.”

Ché Ahn: Pastors and Politics? Giving the Church a Backbone

Crucial to note is that the infamous Dred Scott decision did not create slavery but acknowledged and shamefully upheld what had long existed in the United States. To America’s eternal shame, Roe v. Wade actually created the Great American Abortion Holocaust, an unprecedented crime against humanity.

Directly applicable to the abortion question is Lincoln’s reasoning, which refutes both Douglas and Mississippi’s argument in Dobbs:

“When Judge Douglas says that whoever or whatever community wants slaves, they have a right to have them, he is perfectly logical if there is nothing wrong in the institution; but if you admit that it is wrong, he cannot logically say that any body has a right to do wrong.”

“Turn it in any way you can, in all the arguments sustaining the Democratic policy, and in that policy itself, there is a careful, studied exclusion of the idea that there is anything wrong in slavery.”

Mississippi, a former slave state and the last to ratify the 13th Amendment, shows a remarkable lack of historical self-awareness when it asks the high court in its brief to “allow the people to address this hard issue,” meaning, to let the states decide the question of evil — knowing many will permit it! Does Mississippi want another Bleeding Kansas, the result of letting the states decide regarding slavery?

Read this side-by-side comparison of the Republican and Democratic Party platforms to see how committed Democrats are to butchering preborn Americans by abortion-homicide.

Remember, today’s Democrats shamelessly promote abortion as a positive good just as Democrats promoted slavery prior to the Civil War, thus self-identifying as the subject of Isaiah 5:20: “Woe to those who call evil good and good evil.”

It is abundantly clear to all who have eyes and ears that the same evil force behind abortion supported and defended slavery to the point of starting the Civil War, which killed about 750,000 soldiers and civilians. The Apostle Paul describes this evil in Ephesians 6:12: “For we do not wrestle against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the cosmic powers over this present darkness, against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly places.”

Although a lifelong slave owner, Thomas Jefferson was conflicted. His fear of the divine consequences of slavery should be everyone’s fear today regarding America’s collective culpability for the ongoing shame of abortion-genocide: “Indeed, I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just [and] that his justice cannot sleep forever.”

With God’s justice in mind, we hope the reader, with those he or she influences, will join us at PreBorn Americans United to pray that the Dobbs court overturns Roe and Casey by ruling that we are constitutional persons deserving protection from the moment of conception. We also hope that pro-life organizations publicly advocate for such prayer.

The views expressed in this opinion article are those of their author and are not necessarily either shared or endorsed by the owners of this website. If you are interested in contributing an Op-Ed to The Western Journal, you can learn about our submission guidelines and process here.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →

We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

PreBorn Americans United is an effort to give a voice to the 63 million innocent Americans and counting who have lost their lives since Roe v. Wade. Please consider supporting this effort with your donations at