Path 27

Tom Brady Reportedly Rejected Alternative 'Deflategate' Punishment

Path 27

We’re learning more about some of the tension inside the New England Patriots organization, and how it might not have been all about Tom Brady and former backup Jimmy Garoppolo.

The fallout from “Deflategate” was more than just the four-game suspension Brady received from the NFL.

Apparently, the perceived lack of support from his own team had a huge effect as well, according to an ABC News report on a new book.

In “12: The Inside Story of Tom Brady’s Fight for Redemption,” authors Casey Sherman and Dave Wedge report that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell gave the quarterback the option of a $1 million fine in lieu of a suspension if he conceded that his footballs had been deflated.

“(Goodell) demanded that Brady state publicly that former Patriots equipment guys (John) Jastremski and (Jim) McNally had purposely tampered with footballs, even without his knowledge,” the book says.

GOP Rep Says He Hugged Cop Who Shot Ashli Babbitt and Said 'You Did What You Had to Do'

According to the authors’ research, Brady flat-out refused to make Patriots staffers scapegoats for the deflated footballs.

“There’s no way I’m gonna ruin these guys for something I believe they didn’t do,” Brady told NFLPA director DeMaurice Smith, according to the book.

The Athletic ran an excerpt of the book, in which Patriots owner Robert Kraft announced the team would accept Brady’s suspension.

“So in that spirit, I don’t want to continue the rhetoric that’s gone on for the last four months,” he told reporters. “I’m going to accept, reluctantly, what he (Goodell) has given us, and not to continue this dialogue and rhetoric, and we won’t appeal.”

Will 'Deflategate' hurt Tom Brady's legacy?

When Brady called Smith during Kraft’s news conference, he began with an expletive.

“What the f—?” Brady shouted over the phone, according to the book. “Why am I not getting the support I deserve on this thing?”

Goodell’s offer and Brady’s subsequent refusal are noteworthy, as it’s the first time any suspension alternative has been mentioned publicly.

It’s also worth repeating that because the quarterback refused to blame equipment managers, he paid the ultimate price.

Brady ended up being suspended four games to start the 2016 season, a stretch in which New England went 3-1 behind Garoppolo and third-stringer Jacoby Brissett.

NFL Announces New Rules That Could Inflict Massive Punishments on Teams with Unvaccinated Players

The season ended with the Patriots coming back from 28-3 to beat Atlanta in the Super Bowl and Brady winning his fourth Super Bowl MVP award.

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →


We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

, , ,
Path 27
Mike is an 11-time Michigan Emmy Award winner who has spent nearly 30 years working in sports media.
Mike has spent nearly 30 years in all aspects of sports media, including on-air, 10 at ESPN and another 10 at Fox Sports Detroit. He now works as a TV agent, and lives with his family in West Bloomfield, MI.
Sudbury, Massachusetts
11-time Michigan Emmy winner
Emerson College
Books Written
The Longest Year: One Family's Journey Of Life, Death, And Love/If These Walls Could Talk: Detroit Tigers/If These Walls Could Talk: Detroit Lions
Topics of Expertise