Parler Share

Zoom Hearing Goes Horribly Wrong When Alleged Abuser Is Discovered Inside Victim's Own Home

Parler Share

COVID has put a halt to many of our normal ways of functioning, including the way that courts work. As with many other jobs, the work has been taken online — and not without its drawbacks.

Other than the garden variety shenanigans that can take place thanks to people in the background of video conference calls, even the most serious of proceedings can have their hiccups.

This particular issue was a first for Judge Jeffrey Middleton — but thanks to the keen eye of the prosecuting attorney’s assistant, the situation was resolved.

The Zoom hearing was underway for charges leveled against 21-year-old Coby James Harris of Sturgis, Michigan. He and his girlfriend at the time, Mary Lindsey, had gotten into an argument on Feb. 9 that resulted in a charge against him for “assault with intent to commit bodily harm less than murder,” according to the Sturgis Journal.

The hearing proceeded for some seven minutes before Deborah Davis, representing Lindsey, voiced a concern based on what she’d seen from Lindsey since the video started.

White House Scrubs Kamala Harris' North Korea Gaffe from the Official Transcript - But the Video Lives On

“Your Honor, I have reason to believe that the defendant is in the same apartment as the complaining witness right now, and I am extremely scared for her safety,” Davis said.

“And the fact that she’s looking off to the side and he’s moving around, I want some confirmation that she is safe before we continue.”

To suss out whether or not the two were in close proximity, the judge questioned where they were at that moment, asking first Lindsey and then Harris.

“Um, I’m at a house,” Lindsey said. She gave an address on Hatch Street.

Harris gave an East Lafayette Street address.

To confirm, Middleton asked Harris to go outside, take a photo of the address number, and send it. Harris demurred, saying he couldn’t because his phone was plugged in and charging because his battery was low.

Thankfully, the police had been called and were waiting outside Lindsey’s door.

“We may need to adjourn this, your Honor,” Davis said.

Devastating Story Unfolds After Cops Find 12-Year-Old Girl in Street with Self-Inflicted Gunshot Wound

Lindsey was directed to answer the door, and Davis asked her to take her phone with her so she could make sure she got out safely. Moments later it became clear that Harris was, indeed, in the same building as Lindsey and had lied.

He immediately began to try to explain himself.

“Your Honor, me and Mary both don’t want the no-contact,” he said. “I ask that be dropped. I’m sorry I lied to you. I knew the cops were outside. I don’t know why I…”

The judge promptly suggested that he be quiet.

“Mr. Harris, my advice is, don’t say anything else,” Middleton said. “Take the cigarette out of your mouth. The hearing is adjourned. Your bond is canceled. If you have $10 million, you can’t bond out. In addition, the prosecutor’s probably also going to charge you with obstruction of justice.”

The original charge Harris faced was a felony charge that could result in up to 10 years of prison time. Now, he might face more.

It was certainly an unusual situation and one that the judge had never experienced before.

“This is an issue we didn’t have when we were having live court,” he said. “This is the first time, to my knowledge … that this has occurred. Kudos to the Sturgis Police Department for following up on this.”

Truth and Accuracy

Submit a Correction →

We are committed to truth and accuracy in all of our journalism. Read our editorial standards.

, , ,
Parler Share
Amanda holds an MA in Rhetoric and TESOL from Cal Poly Pomona. After teaching composition and logic for several years, she's strayed into writing full-time and especially enjoys animal-related topics.
As of January 2019, Amanda has written over 1,000 stories for The Western Journal but doesn't really know how. Graduating from California State Polytechnic University with a MA in Rhetoric/Composition and TESOL, she wrote her thesis about metacognitive development and the skill transfer between reading and writing in freshman students.
She has a slew of interests that keep her busy, including trying out new recipes, enjoying nature, discussing ridiculous topics, reading, drawing, people watching, developing curriculum, and writing bios. Sometimes she has red hair, sometimes she has brown hair, sometimes she's had teal hair.
With a book on productive communication strategies in the works, Amanda is also writing and illustrating some children's books with her husband, Edward.
Austin, Texas
Languages Spoken
English und ein bißchen Deutsch
Topics of Expertise
Faith, Animals, Cooking